What Is a Cooling Tower? Key Terms, Types and Maintenance Explained
What Is a Cooling Tower?
Cooling water quality is a function of many variables, and cooling itself is a process that combines multiple factors, multiple variables and multiple effects. On this basis, industry experts have carried out extensive research and improvement work.
A cooling tower is mainly used in air-conditioning cooling systems, refrigeration systems, injection molding, leather making, foaming, power generation, steam turbines, aluminum profile processing, air compressors, industrial water cooling and other fields. The largest applications are air-conditioning cooling, refrigeration, and the plastics and chemical industries. Specific fields include:
Manufacturing and processing industries: food, pharmaceuticals, metal casting, plastics, rubber, textiles, steel mills, chemicals, petrochemical products, etc.
In practical engineering applications, many other factors also need to be considered.
Key Terms of Cooling Towers
Drift
Drift refers to the fine water droplets carried out of the tower with the hot, moist exhaust air. The concentration of impurities in drift droplets is the same as that of the circulating water entering the tower. Drift eliminators (also called water-removal devices) such as baffles are usually installed to reduce drift loss: after the air passes through the fill and the spraying zone, the entrained droplets are removed by the eliminator before the air leaves the tower.
Windage (splash-out)
Windage refers to water droplets blown out near the air inlet of the tower. When the wind is strong, water may also be lost through splashing. Wind screens, louvers, splash deflector plates and flow regulating devices can be installed to limit these losses.
Plume
A plume is the visible water-vapor plume formed outside the tower when the saturated moist air discharged from the cooling tower meets the surrounding cold air. After the hot moist air leaves the top of the tower, its water vapor condenses into fine droplets on contact with cold air, forming a white plume, much like the breath exhaled from a person's mouth in cold weather.
Noise
Noise is the sound energy emitted by the cooling tower into its surroundings, which can be measured (and recorded) at a given distance and direction. It mainly comes from aerodynamic noise caused by the rotation of the fan blades, and mechanical noise from the motor, gearbox, drive belts and other components.
Legionella Risk
After long-term operation, bacteria will grow inside a cooling tower, the typical species being Legionella, which can cause infectious disease and affects an area of about 800 meters around every cooling tower. Urban cooling towers are a major source of urban pollution. Legionella is transmitted through the air. The water tank of an air-conditioning system is an ideal breeding ground for the bacterium, which can spread throughout an entire building through ductwork. People who stay in air-conditioned rooms for long periods should therefore take particular care.
Counterflow vs. Crossflow Cooling Towers
Counterflow towers
In a counterflow tower, water flows downward through the fill while air flows horizontally into the tower from outside, so the two flows cross at right angles. This type is often used in residential areas with strict noise requirements and is the most widely used cooling tower in the air-conditioning sector. Advantages: energy saving, low water pressure, low air resistance, suitable for low-speed motors, no dripping noise or aerodynamic noise, and convenient maintenance of the fill and water distribution system. In the section between the fill and the water collecting basin, water is further cooled by falling droplets - the so-called "tail effect" - which lowers the water temperature by 1-2 °C in northern China. In summary, under the same conditions a counterflow tower needs about 20% less fill volume than a crossflow tower, and its heat exchange process is more rational and gives higher cooling efficiency.
Crossflow towers
In a crossflow tower, attention should be paid to the following points: the frame requires about 40% more material; heat exchange requires a larger fill volume; the fill ages easily; the water distribution holes clog easily; freeze protection is poor; and wet-air recirculation is large. The advantages of the crossflow tower are exactly the disadvantages of the counterflow tower, and vice versa.
Water distribution and operation
The water distribution system of a counterflow tower is not easily clogged; the fill stays clean and does not age quickly; wet-air recirculation is small; and freeze-protection and ice-melting measures are easier to implement. Multiple units can be combined: in winter, to obtain the required water temperature and flow, several units can be merged, operated as a single unit, or fans can be stopped entirely. Construction, installation and maintenance are easy and inexpensive, so these towers are commonly used in large and medium-sized air-conditioning and industrial cooling water circuits.
Spray-Filled and Closed-Circuit Cooling Towers
Spray (fill-free) towers
Special spray nozzles are installed at the upper air inlet at the bottom of the tower, with either fan-free self-rotating spray air supply or top exhaust. Hot water is atomized into fine mist as it passes through the swirl vanes inside the nozzle, so the mist exists in two cooling stages - upward co-current spraying and downward counterflow falling. The atomization is uniform without hollow cones, the cooling effect is stable, power consumption is low, the drift rate is 0.01%, no fill is required, and cost is low with long service life, complying with the national standard GB7190.1-1997. Application fields: metallurgy, food, chemical industry, high-turbidity, high-temperature and anti-corrosion cooling towers.
Closed-circuit (evaporative) cooling towers
A closed-circuit cooling tower (also called an evaporative air cooler) places a tubular heat exchanger inside the tower and achieves cooling through heat exchange among the flowing air, spray water and circulating water. Because it is a closed loop, water quality is protected from pollution, the efficient operation of the main equipment is well protected and service life is extended. When the outside temperature is low, the spray water system can be shut off to save water. With the implementation of national energy-saving and emission-reduction policies and the increasing scarcity of water resources, closed-circuit cooling towers have been widely used in steel and metallurgy, power and electronics, machining, air conditioning and other industries.
In northern China the winter temperature is usually below zero, so the freeze protection of closed-circuit cooling towers is an increasingly prominent problem: if it is not solved properly, the heat exchange tubes or other tower components may be damaged by freezing. Depending on the process, some closed-circuit towers run all winter, some run only part of the time, and some are almost unused - but all need freeze protection. If a closed-circuit cooling tower does not need to operate in winter, the spray water and internal circulating water must be drained when it is shut down.
Closed-circuit cooling towers are suitable for various cooling systems with high requirements on circulating water quality, and have broad application prospects in electric power, chemical industry, steel, food and many other industrial sectors. On the other hand, compared with air-cooled heat exchangers, evaporative cooling towers use the latent heat of evaporation of water on the underside of the tubes to significantly enhance heat and mass transfer on the air side, which is also a clear advantage.
Fan Energy-Saving Control
The purpose of fan energy-saving control management is to achieve closed-loop automatic control of fan operation. The water supply temperature is preset according to production needs; the influence of climate and weather on water temperature and the change of system heat-transfer conditions are reflected in time by the measured values of temperature sensors, and the energy consumption of the cooling equipment is finally regulated to stabilize the water supply temperature, achieving automatic energy saving.
Variable-frequency speed regulation (VFD) is generally regarded as the ideal way to accomplish this, but its use on circulating-water cooling-tower fans has the following limitations and defects:
The energy loss of the frequency converter itself (average operating efficiency below 90%) reduces the energy-saving effect.
The design must also consider destructive resonance when the converter runs at certain specific speeds, and strong electromagnetic interference from the converter affecting other instruments.
For circulating-water systems with high-power, few-unit fans, starting or stopping one fan greatly changes the water temperature, so energy-saving controllers can hardly stabilize the water temperature, and it is difficult to select proper parameters such as the permissible temperature deviation and the execution cycle; the goal of energy saving can hardly be reached. In this situation, automatic variable-frequency speed regulation is more suitable for fan management.
Fan Safety Monitoring
The purpose of fan safety monitoring management is to automatically detect changes in operating parameters such as fan vibration, oil temperature and oil level, display and record them, and give alarms and shut down fans whose measured values exceed limits, so as to achieve safe and smooth fan operation and reduce or even eliminate fan damage accidents.
Fan safety monitoring systems usually adopt multi-parameter combined probe technology, digital command coding technology and computer network management technology. The combined probe is installed on the fixed seat of the fan gearbox oil dipstick, with its rod inserted directly into the lubricating oil, converting the oil temperature, oil level and equipment vibration inside the gearbox into electrical signals and transmitting them remotely to the monitor in the control room. One monitor can be connected by cable to several combined probes to monitor multiple fans in real time, providing digital display, over-limit alarm and over-limit shutdown functions.
The monitoring system can be connected to a management computer through a four-core communication cable (RS-422 standard serial interface); the computer can be a general-purpose PC or an industrial computer. With suitable configuration and monitoring software, networked control of several monitors can be achieved, adding further functions to the fan monitors.
Safety monitors still have shortcomings, mainly in oil-level monitoring. Due to harsh conditions, sensors are prone to faults such as scaling of the hot wire or broken wires caused by water in the lubricating oil; if probe maintenance is not timely, manual inspection on the tower is still required.
Water Losses and Makeup
Under certain conditions, cooling towers may cause hazards such as spray or icing in the surrounding area. Note that what is lost by evaporation during cooling is relatively pure water, whereas drift is the fine droplets carried out with the air, which account for only a small proportion of the water.
Because the cooling water circulates repeatedly, the concentration of dissolved solids keeps increasing, water quality deteriorates and algae grow easily; therefore part of the water must be blown down and replaced with fresh makeup water.
Evaporation loss: cooling towers used for air conditioning are usually designed with a 5 °C temperature range, and the required makeup water is about 2% of the circulating water volume.
Drift (splash) loss: depends on the tower design, wind speed and other factors; under normal conditions it is about 0.1-0.2% of the circulating water volume.
Blowdown loss: depends on water quality and the concentration of dissolved solids, generally about 0.3% of the circulating water volume.
Scale, Corrosion and Cleaning
Most cooling water contains calcium and magnesium ions and acid carbonates. When the cooling water flows over metal surfaces, carbonates are deposited. In addition, oxygen dissolved in the cooling water causes metal corrosion and forms rust. Because of these deposits, the heat transfer of the cooling tower declines; in severe cases, cooling water has to be sprayed on the outside of the shell, and heavy scaling can block the tubes and disable heat exchange. Research data show that scale deposits have a huge impact on heat-transfer loss, and as deposits grow, energy costs rise. Even a very thin layer of scale increases the operating cost of the scaled part of the equipment by more than 40%. Keeping the cooling channels free of mineral deposits improves efficiency, saves energy, extends equipment service life, and saves production time and cost.
Traditional cleaning methods such as mechanical cleaning (scraping, brushing), high-pressure water and chemical cleaning (acid pickling) have many problems: they cannot thoroughly remove scale and other deposits; the acid corrodes the equipment and forms holes; residual acid causes secondary corrosion or under-deposit corrosion, ultimately requiring equipment replacement; and the spent cleaning solution is toxic and requires substantial funds for wastewater treatment. In view of the above, a cleaning agent with low metal corrosivity, high efficiency, environmental friendliness and safety should be selected; such agents not only clean well but also do not corrode the equipment, ensuring long-term use of the cooling tower.
Surface Protection and Anti-Corrosion Coating
After the surface treatment of the cooling tower passes acceptance, the prepared epoxy primer should be brushed within 6 hours. The primer connects the substrate and the top coats and has excellent adhesion. Before the first coat, the tower surface should be wiped clean with cotton yarn dipped in gasoline to remove dirt and floating dust. The primer must be uniform, without sagging, missed spots, pinholes or bubbles, and the paint film should be smooth with consistent thickness (25-35 μm, dosage 80-90 g/m2).
Corners and internal/external angles need an extra pass. When brushing vertical surfaces, work top-down, left-to-right, difficult parts first, with staggered strokes. After the first primer has cured naturally, clean the surface again and apply the second coat of epoxy coal-tar glass-flake primer (35-40 μm, about 100 g/m2). Uneven areas, cracks and leaks on concrete tower surfaces should be filled and leveled with epoxy putty before the second coat is applied.
After the epoxy primer has cured naturally for 24 hours and dried, pass acceptance, and the intermediate epoxy coal-tar glass-flake paint can be applied by the same method (110-125 g/m2 per coat, film thickness 45 μm), ensuring no pinholes, sagging or missed spots; the surface should be flat, uniform, full and consistent in gloss. After the intermediate paint has dried completely and passed inspection, remove floating dust and apply the first top coat of epoxy coal-tar glass-flake paint (100-125 g/m2, thickness 40-50 μm); after it dries, apply the second top coat (80-100 μm). The final top coat is the key step: the paint must be full, uniform in color, smooth and flat, with a certain gloss and a consistent, attractive appearance.
Materials, Tube Sheets and Weld Corrosion
Cooling towers are usually made of carbon steel, stainless steel and copper. When a carbon-steel tube sheet is used in a cooling tower, the welds between the tube sheet and the tubes often suffer corrosion leakage; the leaked material enters the cooling water system, polluting the environment and wasting material.
During fabrication, welding of the tube sheet and tubes is generally manual arc welding, and the weld shape has defects of varying degrees, such as depressions, porosity and slag inclusion, with uneven weld stress distribution. In service, the tube sheet contacts industrial cooling water, and the impurities, salts, gases and microorganisms in the water corrode the tube sheet and welds. Research shows that industrial water, whether fresh or sea water, contains various ions and dissolved oxygen, and changes in chloride-ion and oxygen concentration play an important role in the corrosion pattern; the complexity of the metal structure also affects the corrosion morphology.
Maintenance and Thermal Calculation
Routine maintenance
The gearbox oil level should be checked frequently. Recommended lubricants are No. 22-28 hypoid gear oil or No. 90-120 industrial gear oil; use higher-viscosity oil in summer. After the first 500 hours of operation, drain the oil and replace it with new oil.
Before starting the fan, motor and gearbox, check them according to the relevant product manuals, especially the motor wiring: follow the wiring diagram provided by the motor manufacturer, as inconsistent representations can easily cause wiring errors. Start in sequence from low speed to high speed. After the blade angles are set to the catalog values, if the current at high speed exceeds the rated value, stop the machine and readjust the blade angles. Adjustment standards: (A) mark the upper and lower edges of each blade 150 mm from the casing, and the height difference Δh between the two marks of each blade - the difference between the largest and smallest Δh must not exceed 2 mm; (B) the elevation of the upper blade edge 150 mm from the casing - the difference between the largest and smallest values must not exceed 0.002R (R is the fan radius); (C) the motor current at high speed equals 0.9-0.95 of the rated value.
FRP (glass fiber reinforced plastic) is combustible, so open flames are not allowed during cooling tower maintenance. If open flames are necessary, corresponding safety measures must be taken, approved by the fire and safety authorities, with dedicated firefighting personnel and equipment on site. Flame-retardant FRP can be ordered at additional cost.
Technical indicators such as thermal performance, noise and vibration are the design responsibility of the Fourth Design and Research Institute of the Ministry of Machinery Industry, and the cooling tower manufacturer is responsible for product quality. If the institute is needed to supervise quality, a tripartite technical agreement among the user, the manufacturer and the institute can be signed.
Thermal calculation
The purpose of cooling tower thermal calculation is twofold: first, given the water load and heat load, to determine the required tower area under specific meteorological conditions according to the cooling requirements; second, given the tower parameters, to calculate the cooled water temperature under specific water load, heat load and meteorological conditions. In engineering design, when selecting a complete packaged cooling tower, the fill height, volume, air volume and known conditions are used to check whether the cooled water temperature meets the requirement.
There are many calculation methods for cooling towers. Some methods are quite accurate but too cumbersome and generally not used. For mechanical-draft cooling towers, the Merkel enthalpy-difference method or graphical methods are most common. When a mechanical-draft cooling tower is selected directly for a refrigeration installation, the calculation charts in the product catalog can be used.
Fill specifications
Cooling tower fill: PVC inclined-corrugated fill in sizes 125, 200, 230, 250 and 300; inclined-corrugated square-tower fill in 1000 mm × 500 mm and 1200 mm × 500 mm.