Research Progress in RO Concentrate Treatment Technology for Refining and Chemical Wastewater
Authors: Xu Baozhu1, Jian Xiaowen2, Zhang Xuli2, Tang Huajun2
1 Quality, Health, Safety and Environmental Protection Department, PetroChina Jinxi Petrochemical Company, Huludao 125000, Liaoning, China
2 SINOKLE Technology Co., Ltd., Shenzhen 518000, Guangdong, China
Abstract: Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) show great potential in the treatment of reverse osmosis (RO) concentrate from refining and chemical plants. This paper reviews the current application of AOPs to RO concentrate treatment and discusses the latest progress of AOP-based treatment of refining wastewater; the AOP technologies covered include photocatalysis, catalytic ozonation, Fenton and Fenton-like oxidation, and electrochemical oxidation.
Keywords: RO concentrate; advanced oxidation; Fenton; photocatalysis; ozone oxidation; electrochemical oxidation
1 Overview
In the refining industry today, wastewater treatment mainly combines biological treatment with membrane separation, the process train comprising biological filters, sedimentation tanks, adsorption tanks, ultrafiltration and reverse osmosis. Organics in the water reduce the efficiency of evaporation and crystallisation and may cause scaling or blocking of the equipment, so the organics in RO concentrate must be treated.
AOPs oxidise and degrade pollutants that ordinary oxidants cannot touch by generating strongly oxidising hydroxyl radicals (·OH). The process uses strong oxidants such as hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), ozone (O3) and high-valence metals, combined with catalysts, high pressure, electric fields or light, to produce large numbers of radicals that effectively oxidise and decompose organic pollutants, ultimately converting them into CO2 and H2O. Thanks to their fast reaction, high efficiency and wide applicability, AOPs are regarded as one of the most promising technologies for treating refining RO concentrate. This paper reviews the principles and current applications of photocatalysis, catalytic ozonation, Fenton and Fenton-like reactions, and electrochemical oxidation within the AOP family, with the aim of providing a reference for RO concentrate treatment in refining and chemical plants.
2 Characteristics of refining RO concentrate
The water quality of refining RO concentrate is closely related to the pretreatment process: RO membranes reject most inorganic ions and organics, so the salt content, conductivity and total hardness on the concentrate side rise markedly. Such wastewater has the following features. 1) Refractory organic pollutants: the organics are diverse and include phenols, heterocyclics and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and their bioaccumulation causes persistent harm to organisms and the environment. 2) Complex composition: RO concentrate contains a wide range of organics, inorganics and heavy metals, making its composition extremely complex. 3) High salinity: chloride salts, iron salts and other salts in RO concentrate raise the conductivity of the water, interfere with the normal operation of wastewater treatment facilities and block the pipes of the treatment system. 4) Large water quality fluctuations: both the quality and the quantity of RO concentrate vary considerably, which requires the treatment system to be highly adaptable and stable. Given these characteristics, effective treatment technologies must be adopted to reduce the environmental impact.
3 Current status of refinery RO concentrate treatment at home and abroad
China has newly formulated and issued the Emission Standard of Pollutants for the Petrochemical Industry (GB 31571-2015), which lowers the direct discharge limit for chemical oxygen demand from 80 mg/L to 60 mg/L. The discharge standards for refinery RO concentrate are therefore becoming ever stricter, while the complex nature of the concentrate makes its advanced treatment costly. In view of the characteristics of refinery RO concentrate, developing cost-effective new water treatment processes is of far-reaching significance for the rapid development of the petrochemical industry and for environmental protection. At present, the treatment of refining concentrate at home and abroad mainly follows the directions below.
(1) Reuse: in the advanced treatment train of refinery wastewater, the reflux ratio of RO concentrate should preferably be around 60%; if the reflux rate is controlled at about 80%-90%, scaling of the unit components readily occurs.
(2) Direct or indirect discharge: in coastal and riverside areas, the tidal and ocean current patterns can be used to promote dilution and dispersion of the concentrate when it is discharged; in some desert areas, RO concentrate may be discharged through deep-well injection or crystallised in evaporation ponds.
(3) Comprehensive utilisation: the high-salt fraction of the concentrate has some economic value, and some refineries use ion exchange, electrodialysis, electrosorption and high-pressure reverse osmosis to recover the inorganic salts from high-salinity concentrate that has been reused several times.
(4) Pollutant removal: at present, the conventional technologies for removing organics from RO concentrate include adsorption, biological treatment, chemical oxidation and AOPs. Within AOPs, O3, H2O2 and Fenton reagent all show very strong oxidising power, and electrochemical methods can also effectively degrade the organics in RO concentrate so that the chemical oxygen demand (COD) meets the discharge standard [1].
4 AOPs for treating refining wastewater
Depending on the radical generation mechanism and the reaction environment, AOPs can be divided mainly into ozonation, electrocatalytic oxidation, photocatalysis, Fenton oxidation and Fenton-like processes.
4.1 Photocatalytic oxidation
Photocatalytic oxidation technology originated with Professors Fujishima and Honda, who used TiO2 to catalyse hydrogen production under sunlight; that experiment opened the way for photocatalysis in the environmental field [2]. In a semiconductor material the band structure consists of the valence band, the conduction band and the forbidden band between them. The valence band is the region of lower electron energy and the conduction band the region of higher electron energy; the energy gap between them is called the band gap width. When the energy of a photon exceeds this band gap, an electron in the valence band absorbs the photon energy and jumps to the conduction band, a process known as the generation of photogenerated carriers. During the transition a hole is left in the valence band and a corresponding electron appears in the conduction band; these electrons and holes form electron-hole pairs. Such pairs can take part in various chemical reactions on the semiconductor surface. Holes in particular have strong oxidising power and can oxidise H2O or OH- to produce highly reactive intermediates such as hydroxyl radicals. These active intermediates then react with organic pollutants, mineralising them into water, carbon dioxide and other harmless small molecules. The process is of great value in environmental remediation and pollutant degradation.
Because of its excellent chemical stability, high catalytic activity and low toxicity, TiO2 is considered the best photocatalytic oxidation catalyst available today. Work by Khan [3] showed that, when TiO2 was used as the catalyst for photocatalytic oxidation of refinery wastewater, a COD removal rate as high as 40.68% could be achieved. Furthermore, when an iron-doped TiO2 catalyst was combined with H2O2, the COD removal rate for phenol-bearing wastewater reached 94.8%, which demonstrates that combining catalysts can markedly improve efficiency in specific wastewater treatment. Photocatalytic oxidation is favoured for its mild reaction conditions, low operating cost and easy combination with other AOPs.
Although photocatalysis shows many advantages in refining wastewater treatment, the technology is still at laboratory stage and faces many challenges in large-scale industrial application, such as the high cost and difficult recovery of catalysts, the high energy consumption of ultraviolet light sources, and the low utilisation of visible light by existing catalysts, which results in a low probability of hole generation and poor conversion efficiency. Developing photocatalysts that are efficient, stable, inexpensive and able to use visible light is therefore the key challenge in applying photocatalytic technology to high-concentration organic wastewater and in achieving industrial application.
4.2 Ozonation
In recent years many researchers at home and abroad have focused on developing AOPs that use ozone as the main oxidant and have achieved notable results. In wastewater treatment by ozonation, organic matter is oxidised mainly through two pathways: direct oxidation (reaction with the ozone molecule) and indirect oxidation (radical reactions). The initiation, propagation and termination of radicals generate a variety of radical species, which break down the organics; the process usually takes place in an alkaline environment, under illumination or under the influence of other specific factors. In general the direct reaction of the ozone molecule is fast but highly selective, whereas indirect oxidation is more thorough and can break most of the chemical bonds in organic matter.
Ozonation shows clear advantages in RO concentrate treatment. However, ozonation alone suffers from high operating cost and low ozone utilisation. Studies indicate that raising the pH, or introducing H2O2 or persulphate, can effectively increase the reaction rate. Catalytic ozonation has attracted wide attention, and research on heterogeneous ozone catalysts in particular has produced a series of results. Comprehensive analysis shows that ozone catalysts mainly comprise metal oxides such as iron oxides (Fe2O3, Fe3O4), manganese oxides (MnO2) and copper oxides (CuO, CuO2), supported catalysts such as copper-cobalt-nickel on alumina (CuCoNi/Al2O3), and natural minerals such as zeolite and kaolin. Chen et al. successfully prepared a modified activated carbon catalyst loaded with iron oxide and used it to treat ozonated heavy-oil processing wastewater. The results showed that, compared with ozone alone, the ozone-catalysis test group with AC raised the COD removal rate of heavy-oil wastewater by 36%.
Some innovative domestic enterprises have also worked for many years on the industrial application of catalytic ozonation and have achieved substantial results. SINOKLE, for example, has independently developed an integrated catalytic ozonation and flotation unit that combines multiple catalytic ozonation, hydrodynamic cavitation and cyclonic flotation; it is the first integrated ozone-flotation unit in China. SINOKLE has also independently developed a series of silica-alumina-based and carbon-based ozone catalysts, and with these two catalyst types the unit shows great advantages in the treatment of oily wastewater, landfill leachate and high-salinity RO concentrate. Treating the RO concentrate of a refinery in Yumen with this unit, at a pH of about 7 and an ozone dosage ratio of 1.2, gave a COD removal rate of more than 65%, providing an effective technology for advanced treatment of high-salinity oily wastewater.
4.3 Fenton and Fenton-like oxidation
Fenton oxidation uses hydrogen peroxide and ferrous ions to oxidise organics under acidic conditions and was proposed by the French scholar Fenton [4]. Since Fenton reagent was first introduced to the treatment of phenol and alkylbenzene wastewater in 1964, the method has rapidly become a new research direction in environmental engineering. The advent of Fenton technology not only improved treatment efficiency but also provided new ideas and methods for subsequent environmental remediation and protection. The standard [Fe2+]/[H2O2] ratio of Fenton reagent is 1:2, but industry commonly uses 1:5 to improve efficiency.
The oxidation process of Fenton reagent involves Fe2+ acting as a catalyst in an acidic environment to promote the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and thereby generate hydroxyl radicals; this further triggers a series of radical chain reactions. Fenton oxidation is noted for simple operation, a fast reaction rate and the ability to oxidise and decompose poorly biodegradable organics in wastewater. However, the method also has limitations, such as the large amount of waste residue it may generate and the secondary pollution this causes, and the fact that Fe3+ readily leaves with the treated water; these problems restrict its wide industrial use.
To address the limitations of Fenton oxidation effectively, researchers have proposed Fenton-like processes. Electro-Fenton oxidation, for example, generates H2O2 or ferrous ions (Fe2+) by electrolysis. Photo-Fenton oxidation, under ultraviolet or visible light, increases the content of iron hydroxyl complexes that absorb light and decompose, producing more hydroxyl radicals. Fenton and Fenton-like processes are gradually being applied to wastewater treatment in the dye, pharmaceutical and petrochemical industries.
4.4 Electrocatalytic oxidation
Electrochemical oxidation technology uses the high potential and catalytic action of the anode and cathode after a current is applied, or the strongly oxidising radicals generated during electrolysis, to convert organics into small readily biodegradable molecules, thereby lowering their biological toxicity and improving the biodegradability of the wastewater. With its mild reaction conditions, need for nothing but electrical energy, high efficiency and small footprint, the technology has attracted wide attention and is widely used in refining RO concentrate treatment. During electrochemical oxidation the very high potential of the anode can oxidise organics, for example first converting them into small molecules such as aliphatic alcohols, aldehydes and ketones and finally into CO2 and H2O. It is worth noting that direct and indirect oxidation mechanisms are not sharply separated in electrochemical oxidation; in practice the two mechanisms often act together.
Given the complexity of RO concentrate, when electrochemical oxidation is used to treat it the electrode material is prone to corrosion and passivation, and hydrogen-evolution and oxygen-absorption corrosion may occur at the cathode, which shortens electrode life. At the same time, electrode preparation is complex and costly. These factors are the key reason why electrocatalytic oxidation has not yet achieved industrial-scale application.
5 Integrated AOP processes
Combining AOPs with other processes can greatly improve the efficiency of AOPs in degrading and separating pollutants. Combining AOPs with biological treatment, for example, allows the AOP to degrade large molecules that are biologically toxic and improve the biodegradability of RO concentrate, after which biological treatment decomposes the residual oil, small-molecule organics and nitrogen. Jain et al. combined the activated sludge process (ASP) with AOPs to treat refining RO concentrate, and the combined process achieved a COD removal rate of more than 80% [5].
AOPs are also combined with membranes as an innovative way of degrading pollutants in wastewater; common applications include combining photocatalysis over semiconductor catalysts with membrane processes. El-Naas et al. reported the use of an anaerobic baffled reactor (ABR) with a biological oxidation process to treat produced water, achieving removal rates of 65% and 88% for heavy oil and grease respectively [6]. Huang et al. examined the feasibility of combining electrocoagulation with membranes; the results showed that the combined process removed 95% of the oil, TOC and COD from refining wastewater and close to 100% of the turbidity, while also removing more than 95% of the inorganic salts, including chlorides, sulphates, sodium, calcium and manganese [7]. Integrated AOP processes further include photocatalysis combined with ultrasound, ozone combined with ultrasound, and Fenton and photo-Fenton processes combined with ultrasound.
6 Concluding remarks
Although AOPs are limited by the severity of their reaction conditions and by relatively high operating costs, and still face challenges in large-scale industrial application, future research should focus on developing high-performance catalysts and electrodes with higher activity, lower cost and wider applicability, so as to simplify the reaction conditions and improve treatment efficiency. In addition, the strategies for combining different AOPs, and their integration with other water treatment technologies, deserve deeper study in order to raise oxidation rates and efficiency further while keeping operating costs under effective control.
References
[1] Wu Zhijing. Research progress of advanced oxidation processes for high-salinity wastewater treatment [J]. Guangdong Chemical Industry, 2024, 51(21): 116-118.
[2] Fujishima A, Honda K. Electrochemical photolysis of water at a semiconductor electrode [J]. Nature, 1972, 238(5358): 37-38.
[3] Garcia C A, Hodaifa G. Real olive oil mill wastewater treatment by photo-Fenton system using artificial ultraviolet light lamps [J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2017, 162: 743-753.
[4] Raji M, Mirbagheri S A. A global trend of Fenton-based AOPs focused on wastewater treatment: a bibliometric and visualization analysis [J]. Water Practice and Technology, 2020, 16: 19-34.
[5] Jain M, Majumder A, Ghosal P S, Gupta A K. A review on treatment of petroleum refinery and petrochemical plant wastewater: a special emphasis on constructed wetlands [J]. Journal of Environmental Management, 2020, 272: 111057.
[6] El-Naas M H, Alhaija M A, Al-Zuhair S. Evaluation of a three-step process for the treatment of petroleum refinery wastewater [J]. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 2014, 2: 56-62.
[7] An C, Huang G, Yao Y, Zhao S. Emerging usage of electrocoagulation technology for oil removal from wastewater: a review [J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2017, 579: 537-556.
The original article was published in Petrochemical Technology, Issue 4, 2025.