Oily Firefighting Wastewater from UHV Converter Transformer Fires: CDFU Plus Modified Activated Carbon

2026-11-17 13:11:05
立即下载

Original authors: Jian Xiaowen, Tang Huajun, Du Shuang, Zhang Yue, Xu Han (SINOKLE Technology Co., Ltd., Shenzhen, 518000)

Abstract: The oily firefighting wastewater generated by fires at UHV (ultra-high voltage) converter transformers consists mainly of petroleum hydrocarbons and surfactants, and no well-established treatment process exists for this type of wastewater so far. This paper proposes a treatment process of CDFU (cyclonic dissolved-air flotation) + modified activated carbon adsorption. The process reduces the oil content of the raw wastewater from 1000 mg/L to below 10 mg/L and the COD from 2974.9 mg/L to below 100 mg/L. The final effluent meets the Class-II standard of the Integrated Wastewater Discharge Standard (GB 8978-1996).

Keywords: oily firefighting wastewater; CDFU; modified activated carbon; treatment process

1. Introduction

In recent years, accidents involving converter transformers at UHV converter stations have occurred frequently, causing serious losses to the safe operation of the stations. Some of these accidents are electrical fires caused by the combustion of insulating oil after power-transforming equipment failure. After an accident, the station's firefighting measures bring the fire under control within a certain period. During extinguishing, the firefighting water (fluoroprotein foam or aqueous film-forming foam, AFFF) mixes with the insulating oil and produces oily firefighting wastewater. This wastewater carries a very high oil load; excessive oil and COD can damage the sludge of downstream wastewater treatment plants and impair their treatment performance, so a series of treatment steps is required before discharge to a downstream plant [1].

Oil contaminants and surfactants are chemically stable macromolecular polymers that cannot be simply removed by conventional water-treatment processes. The main removal technologies currently available include physical, chemical and biological methods and their combinations [2]. Physical methods separate pollutants from the wastewater based on their physicochemical properties; they are low-cost, fast and free of secondary pollution, but their performance at low concentrations is unsatisfactory. Examples include adsorption, membrane filtration, flotation, washing and coagulation. Chemical methods degrade macromolecular organics into small molecules; typical approaches include advanced oxidation, electrochemical treatment, high-temperature incineration, photocatalytic degradation and ultrasonic degradation. Biological methods use microorganisms to biodegrade macromolecular organics into small molecules, similar in effect to chemical methods; they are green, easy to operate and inexpensive, but time-consuming and sensitive to fluctuations in wastewater quality.

Fire accidents are emergencies that require short-duration, high-efficiency treatment. The BOD/COD ratio of this wastewater is low (i.e., poor biodegradability), microbial cultivation takes a long time and requires long-term operation, so biological treatment is unsuitable. The oil concentration is high; chemical methods would face high treatment costs, possible secondary pollution and complex, labor-intensive operation. Adsorption, by contrast, is simple to operate, fast, compact, and activated carbon can adsorb pollutants at elevated temperatures, which fits the conditions of this wastewater very well [3].

The CDFU + modified activated carbon process is efficient and simple, occupies little land, and the modified activated carbon can be regenerated and reused, reducing chemical and labor inputs and saving cost — an effective method for treating this type of wastewater.

Heavy oil contamination raises the TOC of the wastewater to about 2000 mg/L, equivalent to a COD of 4000–5000 mg/L. Pre-treatment with CDFU removes most of the floating oil and emulsified oil; the remaining small fraction of dissolved oil accounts for only about 1% of the total concentration, consisting mainly of short-chain hydrocarbons and relatively low-molecular-weight polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. The hydrophobic and oleophobic nature of C8 fluorinated surfactants makes them a key component of firefighting foams [4], and PFOA and PFOS are among the main pollutants of firefighting wastewater [5], harmful to both plants and animals. Oily firefighting wastewater therefore must not be discharged directly to a wastewater plant; removing PFOS and PFOA also reduces part of the COD [6]. Another important component of firefighting foam is hydrocarbon surfactants. Based on the COD conversion of the oil and fluorinated surfactants, these two categories contribute roughly 40% of the COD; the remaining 60% comes from hydrocarbon surfactants, which can be removed by two-stage modified activated carbon adsorption [7].

2. Experimental Section

2.1 Materials and Instruments

Crude transformer oil, firefighting foam concentrate, COD reagent, CDFU (cyclonic dissolved-air flotation unit), activated carbon, COD analyzer, rapid digester, electric forced-air drying oven, peristaltic pump, electronic analytical balance, separatory funnel, oil-content meter.

2.2 Experimental Methods

Fig. 1 Technical route of the process

Technical route

2.2.1 Test Water

Simulated wastewater was prepared with No. 25 transformer oil taken from the work site and foam solutions of 3%, 5% and 8% (the standard dosage range of firefighting foam). The COD of the wastewater samples was 2656.5, 2790.1 and 2974.9 mg/L respectively, with an oil content of 1000 mg/L in each case.

2.2.2 Experimental Procedure

1. Add 30 mL of foam concentrate to a 1 L volumetric flask, fill with tap water and shake well to prepare a 3% foam solution. Weigh 1 g of No. 25 transformer oil into each of three 1 L beakers, then measure 30 mL, 50 mL and 80 mL of the prepared foam solution with a graduated cylinder, add them to the three beakers and stir well.

Fig. 2 Simulated wastewater

Simulated wastewater

2. Subject the prepared wastewater to simulated oil removal using the cyclonic flotation principle. Sample the treated water and measure and record its COD and oil content.

Fig. 3 Separated oil layer

Separated oil layer

Fig. 4 Wastewater after oil removal

Wastewater after oil removal

3. Rinse the prepared adsorbent with clean water until the effluent is clear, then dry it in an oven at 105 °C for 4 hours. After the moisture has been removed, place it in a desiccator to cool.

4. Measure 100 g of the cooled adsorbent and prepare a clean 250 mL graduated cylinder placed inside a 1 L beaker. Insert the inlet tube of the peristaltic pump into the CDFU effluent and the outlet tube to the bottom of the cylinder, add the 100 g of adsorbent, and start the pump at a flow rate of 10 mL/min. Once the water covers the adsorbent and overflows from the cylinder into the beaker, sample the water in the beaker and measure and record its COD and oil content.

Fig. 5 Experimental setup

Experimental setup

Fig. 6 Peristaltic pump

Peristaltic pump

3. Results and Discussion

3.1 Removal Performance of the CDFU Stage

Table 1 CDFU treatment performance

Water sampleCOD (mg/L)COD removalOil content (mg/L)Oil removal
3% foam solution + 1000 ppm transformer oil2656.5—1000—
CDFU effluent130.695%999.1%
5% foam solution + 1000 ppm transformer oil2790.1—1000—
CDFU effluent240.391.3%699.4%
8% foam solution + 1000 ppm transformer oil2974.9—1000—
CDFU effluent359.387.9%799.3%

As shown in Table 1, with an influent oil content of 1000 mg/L, the oil content of the CDFU effluent falls below 10 mg/L, already meeting the Class-II standard of the Integrated Wastewater Discharge Standard (GB 8978-1996), with oil removal above 99%. The effluent COD values are 130.6, 240.3 and 359.3 mg/L, corresponding to COD removal rates of 95%, 91.3% and 87.9% — oil removal also removes most of the COD. The effluent COD does not yet meet the discharge standard; the residual COD consists mainly of dissolved oil, fluorinated surfactants and hydrocarbon surfactants remaining in the firefighting wastewater, and further advanced treatment — modified activated carbon adsorption — is required.

3.2 Advanced Treatment with Activated Carbon

3.2.1 Optimization of Activated Carbon Adsorption Performance

Table 2 Adsorption performance before and after modification

Water sample (8% firefighting wastewater)COD (mg/L)COD removed (mg/L)COD removal rate (10 min EBCT per stage)
CDFU effluent428.8——
Stage-1 activated carbon effluent247.2181.642%
Stage-2 activated carbon effluent156.8272.063%
Stage-1 modified activated carbon effluent149.2279.665%
Stage-2 modified activated carbon effluent73.3355.583%

Commercial activated carbon is mass-produced and insufficiently efficient at removing the COD contributed by surfactant components, so the carbon needs to be modified to enhance its adsorption performance, allowing the effluent to meet the standard while reducing carbon dosage and treatment cost. To better match field conditions, tests used the CDFU effluent of the simulated wastewater prepared with 8% foam solution.

Table 2 shows that, for the same water quality, modified activated carbon adsorbs better than unmodified carbon, confirming that modification enhances adsorption. Modified activated carbon achieves the best COD adsorption, with an effluent COD of 73.3 mg/L and a removal rate of 83%, meeting the Class-II standard of GB 8978-1996. Unmodified carbon performs poorly, with an effluent COD of 156.8 mg/L and a removal rate of only 63%, which fails the discharge requirement. Modified activated carbon is therefore a suitable adsorbent for the advanced treatment of oily firefighting wastewater.

3.2.2 COD Removal by Modified Activated Carbon in Advanced Treatment

The COD adsorption removal rates of modified activated carbon in the CDFU effluents of the 3%, 5% and 8% foam solutions are shown in Table 3. As the COD concentration increases, the adsorption removal rate also increases, indicating that COD adsorption by modified activated carbon follows adsorption kinetics and has not yet reached saturation.

Table 3 Advanced treatment performance for the three solutions

Water sampleCOD (mg/L)Oil content (mg/L)COD removed (mg/L)COD removal rate
3% foam solution CDFU effluent130.69——
After modified activated carbon adsorption (20 min)35.26Not detected95.3473%
5% foam solution CDFU effluent240.36——
After modified activated carbon adsorption (20 min)60.07Not detected180.2375%
8% foam solution CDFU effluent361.27——
After modified activated carbon adsorption (20 min)72.24Not detected288.9680%

4. Conclusions and Outlook

4.1 Conclusions

The effluent of UHV converter transformer firefighting wastewater treated by the combined CDFU + activated carbon adsorption process meets the Class-II standard of the Integrated Wastewater Discharge Standard (GB 8978-1996), demonstrating that the scheme is feasible. Specifically: CDFU provides powerful oil removal with an oil removal rate above 99% and a COD removal rate of about 90%; the modified activated carbon advanced treatment removes about 90% of the remaining COD. It was also found that, for the same water quality, modified activated carbon adsorbs better than unmodified carbon, confirming that modification enhances adsorption, with a COD removal rate of 83% and an effluent COD of 73.3 mg/L.

4.2 Outlook

In oily firefighting wastewater, AFFF foam contains PFOA, whose presence cannot be ignored. China currently has no explicit discharge limits for PFAS substances; the blanket classification as "fluorides not exceeding 1 mg/L" no longer satisfies environmental needs. Other countries have already begun developing PFOA discharge standards, so our subsequent work will focus on the deep removal of PFOA from wastewater by this treatment process.

References

  1. Su Junjie, Liu Jing, Yao Weixuan. Determination of 18 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in soil and firefighting wastewater at chemical fire scenes. Analytical Instruments, 2020(06): 167-169.

  2. Li Nan. Discussion on collection and treatment of firefighting wastewater in petrochemical enterprises. Petrochemical Technology, 2020, 27(05): 204+209.

  3. Tong Xizhen, Shi Baoyou, Xie Yue, Wang Dongsheng. Adsorption removal of PFOS from water by modified activated carbon. Environmental Science, 2012, 33(09): 3132-3138.

  4. Jia Xuhong. Research progress on aqueous film-forming foam extinguishing agents. Guangzhou Chemical Industry, 2015, 43(24): 22-24.

  5. Zhang Chunhui et al. Research progress on treatment technologies for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in typical industrial wastewater. China Environmental Science, 2021, 41(03): 1109-1118.

  6. Zhang Lei et al. Feasibility analysis and recommendations for disposal of typical PFOS/PFOSF-containing waste in China. Research of Environmental Sciences, 2022, 35(08): 1974-1985.

  7. Hong Lei, Ding Qianyun, Qi Xiangkun, Chang Qing. Research progress on removal of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances from water by adsorption. Environmental Chemistry, 2021, 40(07): 2193-2203.

Mobile phone/Whatsapp

+86 18926412206

Email

marketing@sinokle.com

Address

Room 2301, Building 1B, Smart Home, Baolong Street, Longgang District, Shenzhen, China

Phone
E-mail
Map
QQ Service