Why Effluent Fails to Meet Discharge Standards: Common Causes of COD, Ammonia, TN, TP and SS Excursions

2026-11-16 13:05:16
立即下载

In wastewater treatment operation, all kinds of problems come across the operator's desk: COD, ammonia nitrogen, total nitrogen (TN) or suspended solids (SS) that will not meet the discharge limit. This article summarizes the most common causes of effluent non-compliance, covering five aspects: excess organic matter, excess ammonia nitrogen, excess TN, excess TP and excess suspended solids.

1. Effluent Organic Matter (BOD5/COD) Above the Limit

The main function of the conventional activated sludge process is to remove organic pollutants from municipal sewage. A well-designed and well-run activated sludge process discharges effluent with BOD5 and SS both below 20 mg/L.

The main factors that affect organic-matter removal are:

1. Nutrients. In ordinary municipal sewage the nutrients — nitrogen, phosphorus and the rest — are available in ample surplus for the microorganisms. When industrial wastewater makes up a large share of the flow, however, check whether the carbon-to-nitrogen-to-phosphorus ratio satisfies 100:5:1. If the wastewater lacks nitrogen, ammonium salts are normally dosed; if it lacks phosphorus, phosphoric acid or a phosphate salt.

2. pH. Municipal sewage is roughly neutral, normally pH 6.5 to 7.5. A small drop in pH usually comes from anaerobic fermentation in the sewer; a larger drop during the rainy season is usually caused by acid rain, particularly conspicuous in combined sewer systems. A sudden, large swing in pH — up or down — almost always means a large slug of industrial wastewater has entered the works. Adjusting pH normally means dosing sodium hydroxide or sulfuric acid, which raises treatment cost considerably.

3. Oil and grease. When the oil content of the wastewater is high, the aeration equipment works less efficiently; unless the air rate is increased, treatment efficiency falls — and increasing aeration raises cost. A high grease content also degrades the settleability of the activated sludge and, in severe cases, becomes the cause of sludge bulking, pushing effluent SS over the limit. Where the influent carries a high oil load, an oil-removal unit must be added in the pretreatment stage.

4. Temperature. Temperature affects the activated sludge process across the board. First, it changes the activity of the microorganisms: in the cold of winter, without corrective measures, treatment performance declines. Second, it changes the separation performance of the secondary clarifier: a temperature change sets up density currents and short-circuiting in the basin, and lower temperature raises viscosity and worsens sludge settleability. Third, it affects aeration efficiency: in summer, the higher water temperature lowers the dissolved-oxygen saturation concentration, making oxygen transfer harder and aeration less efficient, and the lower air density means the air supply must be increased to deliver the same mass of oxygen.

2. Effluent Ammonia Nitrogen Above the Limit

Ammonia nitrogen is removed in the conventional activated sludge train by adding a nitrification stage — extended aeration at reduced loading. The causes of excess ammonia in the effluent are many:

1. Sludge loading and sludge age. Biological nitrification is a low-loading process, with F/M normally 0.05 to 0.15 kg BOD/kg MLVSS·d. The lower the load, the more completely nitrification proceeds and the higher the conversion of NH3-N to NO3-N. Matching the low load, the solids retention time of a nitrifying system must be long: nitrifying bacteria grow slowly, and if SRT is too short and sludge concentration low, a nitrifying population never establishes itself and no nitrification is obtained. The right SRT depends on temperature and other factors; in a system whose main purpose is nitrogen removal, SRT of 11 to 23 days is typical.

2. Return ratio. Nitrifying systems run a higher return-sludge ratio than the conventional process, mainly because the mixed liquor already carries a large amount of nitrate. If the return ratio is too small, sludge sits too long in the secondary clarifier, denitrification sets in there, and the sludge floats. The return ratio is normally held at 50 to 100 percent.

3. Hydraulic retention time. The HRT of a nitrifying aeration basin is longer than that of an ordinary activated sludge basin — at least 8 hours — because the nitrification rate is far lower than the rate of organic-matter removal, so a longer reaction time is needed.

4. BOD5/TKN ratio. TKN is the sum of organic nitrogen and ammonia nitrogen in the water, and the BOD5/TKN ratio of the influent is an important factor for nitrification. The larger the ratio, the smaller the share of nitrifiers in the sludge, the lower the nitrification rate and the lower the nitrification efficiency under the same operating conditions — and the smaller the ratio, the higher the efficiency. Operating experience at many municipal plants puts the optimum BOD5/TKN around 2 to 3.

5. Nitrification rate. A process parameter specific to nitrifying systems is the nitrification rate: the amount of ammonia nitrogen converted per unit weight of activated sludge per day. It depends on the share of nitrifiers in the sludge, on temperature and on other factors; a typical value is 0.02 g NH3-N/g MLVSS·d.

6. Dissolved oxygen. Nitrifiers are obligate aerobes — without oxygen they stop living — and their oxygen uptake rate is far lower than that of the bacteria that decompose organic matter. Unless oxygen is kept plentiful, the nitrifiers simply lose the competition for it. Dissolved oxygen in the aerobic zone must therefore be kept above 2 mg/L, and raised further in special cases.

7. Temperature. Nitrifiers are highly sensitive to temperature. Below 15 °C the nitrification rate falls off sharply, and below 5 °C their physiological activity stops altogether. This is why excess ammonia in the effluent is especially conspicuous in winter, and particularly at plants in northern regions.

8. pH. Nitrifiers respond sharply to pH: their activity peaks in the range 8 to 9, and below pH 6.0 or above 9.6 it is suppressed and tends to stop. The mixed-liquor pH of a nitrifying system should therefore be kept above 7.0 wherever possible.

3. Effluent Total Nitrogen Above the Limit

Nitrogen removal adds a denitrification stage on top of nitrification. Denitrification is the biochemical process in which nitrate in the wastewater is reduced by microorganisms to nitrogen gas under anoxic conditions. The causes of excess TN in the effluent are many:

1. Sludge loading and sludge age. Because nitrification is the prerequisite of denitrification — only good nitrification gives efficient, stable denitrification — a nitrogen-removal system must also run at low or ultra-low load with a high sludge age.

2. Internal and external return ratios. The external return ratio of a denitrifying system can be smaller than that of a purely nitrifying one: most of the nitrogen in the influent has already been removed, so nitrate in the secondary clarifier is not high and the risk of sludge floating there is small. Denitrifying sludge also settles fast, so — provided the return sludge concentration is met — the return ratio can be lowered to extend the wastewater's residence time in the aeration basin. In a well-run plant the external return ratio can be held below 50 percent, while the internal (mixed-liquor) return ratio is normally held between 300 and 500 percent.

3. Denitrification rate. The denitrification rate is the amount of nitrate denitrified per unit of activated sludge per day. It varies with temperature and other factors; a typical value is 0.06 to 0.07 g NO3-N/g MLVSS·d.

4. Dissolved oxygen in the anoxic zone. For denitrification the lower the DO the better — ideally zero — so the denitrifiers can devote their full effort to nitrate reduction. In real plant operation, however, holding DO below 0.5 mg/L in the anoxic zone is difficult, which constrains the denitrification process and, with it, the effluent TN.

5. BOD5/TN ratio. Denitrifiers reduce nitrate in the course of decomposing organic matter, so the wastewater entering the anoxic zone must carry enough organic carbon. At many plants the sewer network lags behind the works: influent BOD5 comes in below the design value while nitrogen and phosphorus come in at or above it, so the available carbon source cannot meet the demand of denitrification — and excess TN in the effluent follows.

6. pH. Denitrifiers are less sensitive to pH than nitrifiers and metabolize normally between pH 6 and 9, but the optimum range for biological denitrification is 6.5 to 8.0.

7. Temperature. Denitrifiers tolerate temperature swings better than nitrifiers, but denitrification still varies with it: the higher the temperature, the higher the rate, peaking at 30 to 35 °C. Below 15 °C the rate drops markedly, and near 5 °C denitrification nearly stops. To hold nitrogen removal through the winter, the plant must lengthen the SRT, raise the sludge concentration or bring more basins into service.

4. Effluent Total Phosphorus Above the Limit

Phosphorus removal at municipal plants relies mainly on the biological route: an anaerobic zone is placed ahead of the aerobic zone so that phosphorus-accumulating organisms (PAOs) alternate between anaerobic and aerobic states, releasing and then taking up phosphate, and the phosphorus leaves the works with the wasted surplus sludge. Where biological removal cannot meet the limit, chemical dosing can assist: chemical phosphorus removal converts phosphate into insoluble solids by coagulation, precipitation and filtration, separating it from the water. The causes of excess TP after biological removal:

1. Sludge loading and sludge age. The anaerobic-aerobic phosphorus-removal process is a high-F/M, low-SRT system: the higher the F/M and the lower the SRT, the more surplus sludge is wasted — and, at a given phosphorus content of the sludge, the more phosphorus leaves the system. For a system whose main purpose is phosphorus removal, F/M of 0.4 to 0.7 kg BOD5/kg MLSS·d and SRT of 3.5 to 7 days are typical; but the SRT must not be so low that effective BOD5 removal can no longer be guaranteed.

2. BOD5/TP ratio. To guarantee phosphorus removal, the wastewater entering the anaerobic zone should have BOD5/TP above 20. Phosphorus-accumulating bacteria are Acinetobacter, physiologically weak, able to take up only the readily degradable fraction of the organic matter — so the influent must carry sufficient BOD5 for their normal metabolism. At many plants the actual influent carries too little carbon and too much nitrogen and phosphorus, so the BOD5/TP ratio falls short of what biological removal needs and the performance suffers.

3. Dissolved oxygen. The anaerobic zone must be strictly anaerobic — DO below 0.2 mg/L — for the PAOs to release phosphorus effectively and set up the subsequent uptake; the aerobic zone must hold DO above 2.0 mg/L for them to take phosphorus up efficiently. Poor control of DO in either zone sharply degrades biological phosphorus removal. Some plants take river water as influent, with high dissolved oxygen; fed straight to the anaerobic zone, it works against the anaerobic condition and hurts phosphorus release.

4. Return ratio. In an anaerobic-aerobic phosphorus-removal system the return ratio should not be too low: enough return flow is needed to withdraw sludge from the secondary clarifier quickly, before the PAOs meet anaerobic conditions there and release their phosphorus. Given fast sludge withdrawal, keep the return ratio as low as practical, so that the sludge's effective residence in the anaerobic zone is not shortened and phosphorus release is not impaired. Where settling is good, a return ratio of 50 to 70 percent guarantees fast withdrawal.

5. Hydraulic retention time. The HRT in the anaerobic zone is normally 1.5 to 2.0 hours. Too short, and phosphorus release is not guaranteed; the facultative acid-producing bacteria in the sludge also fail to break the large organic molecules down into lower fatty acids for the PAOs to consume, again hurting release. The residence time in the aerobic zone is normally 4 to 6 hours, which guarantees full phosphorus uptake.

6. pH. Low pH favors phosphorus release and high pH favors uptake, while overall removal is the combination of both. In a biological phosphorus-removal system the mixed-liquor pH is best held between 6.5 and 8.0.

As the effluent TP limit keeps tightening, chemical phosphorus removal is applied more and more alongside the biological route. Chemical removal raises phosphorus performance, but dosing chemicals also increases the surplus sludge volume substantially, which in turn increases the sludge to be treated and the cake to be disposed of. In practice the dosing point and dose should be fixed by testing and adjusted promptly, so that effluent phosphorus meets the limit steadily at the lowest possible chemical consumption.

5. Effluent Suspended Solids Above the Limit

Whether effluent SS meets the limit depends mainly on the quality of the sludge in the biological system, on the settling performance of the secondary clarifier, and on whether the plant's process control is sound.

Whether the secondary-clarifier design parameters were chosen properly is a decisive factor. Many municipal plants, to save construction cost, shortened the design HRT and pushed the hydraulic surface load up; in operation these clarifiers repeatedly suffer sludge boilover, and effluent SS goes over the limit. And where process adjustment requires a high sludge concentration in the biological basins, the solids surface load on the clarifier rises too high and the effluent suffers. Designers should therefore leave generous margin on these parameters to give the plant room for control and adjustment.

The principal parameters governing clarifier performance are hydraulic retention time, hydraulic surface load and solids flux.

1. Secondary-clarifier HRT. The length of the wastewater's residence in the clarifier is a key operating parameter: only enough residence time guarantees good flocculation and high settling efficiency. An HRT of 3 to 4 hours is recommended.

2. Hydraulic surface load. For a given settling basin and a given inflow, the size of particle it can remove is fixed: the smallest removable particle is the one whose settling velocity equals the basin's hydraulic surface load. The lower the surface load, the more particles can be removed, the higher the settling efficiency and the lower the effluent SS. Designing the secondary clarifier with a low hydraulic surface load helps sludge and other suspended solids settle effectively; 0.6 to 1.2 m³/m²·h is generally recommended.

3. Solids surface load. The solids surface load is another important factor: the lower it is, the better the sludge thickens in the clarifier; the higher it is, the worse. An excessive solids load pushes the sludge blanket too high, flocs leave with the water before they can settle, and effluent SS suffers. The solids surface load should not exceed 150 kg MLSS/m²·d.

4. Activated-sludge quality. Sludge quality decides whether effluent SS exceeds the limit. Good sludge shows four qualities: good adsorption, high biological activity, good settleability and good thickening. Colloidal pollutants must first be adsorbed onto the floc and then onto the bacteria themselves before they can be metabolized, so sludge with poor adsorption removes colloids poorly. Biological activity is the capacity of the organisms in the floc to metabolize organic pollutants; sludge of low activity removes them slowly. Only sludge that settles well separates cleanly from the water in the clarifier; if settleability deteriorates, separation suffers, the effluent turns turbid and SS goes over the limit — and in severe cases so much sludge washes out that the system loses biomass, which then impairs organic removal in turn. Only sludge that thickens well gives a high wasting concentration in the clarifier; if thickening is poor, the wasting concentration falls and a higher return flow must be carried to keep the return sludge mass up — but a higher return ratio shortens the wastewater's effective residence in the aeration basin, cutting aeration time and hurting treatment.

5. Influent SS/BOD5 ratio. The MLVSS fraction of the sludge is closely tied to the influent SS/BOD5 ratio: a high ratio lowers the MLVSS fraction, a low one raises it. Experience shows that below SS/BOD5 of 1 the MLVSS fraction can stay above 50 percent, while above 5 it falls to 20 to 30 percent. With a low MLVSS fraction the system must carry a longer sludge age to protect nitrification, the sludge ages visibly, and effluent SS goes over the limit.

6. Toxic substances. Strong acid, strong alkali or heavy metals in the influent poison the sludge, cost it its treatment function, and in severe cases disintegrate it so that it cannot settle and effluent SS goes over the limit. The fundamental remedy for sludge poisoning is stricter control of the pollution sources upstream.

7. Temperature. As discussed above, temperature affects the process across the board: microbial activity falls in winter without corrective measures, and the clarifier's separation suffers — density currents and short-circuiting when temperature changes, and poorer settleability as lower temperature raises viscosity.

Mobile phone/Whatsapp

+86 18926412206

Email

marketing@sinokle.com

Address

Room 2301, Building 1B, Smart Home, Baolong Street, Longgang District, Shenzhen, China

Phone
E-mail
Map
QQ Service